I regret trading in my Pixel 8 so early

A Google Pixel 8 and a Google Pixel 10 Pro standing upright against a geometric background, surrounded by floating sad and frustrated emoji icons.

Credit: Lucas Gouveia / Android Police

By Jon Gilbert Published 44 minutes ago Jon has been an author at Android Police since 2021. He primarily writes features and editorials covering the latest Android news, but occasionally reviews hardware and Android apps. His favorite Android device was the Pixel 2 XL, and he regards the three months when he owned an iPhone as a time of the utmost shame. Jon graduated with a History degree in 2018, but quickly realized his writing skills were better put to use writing about tech rather than essays. He started writing and editing for startups shortly after graduating, where he did everything from writing website copy to managing and editing for a group of writers. When he's not sitting at his computer, you can find him working at Warhammer World, reading sci-fi, or turning his speakers up to 11. Sign in to your Android Police account Summary Generate a summary of this story follow Follow followed Followed Like Like Thread Log in Here is a fact-based summary of the story contents: Try something different: Show me the facts Explain it like I’m 5 Give me a lighthearted recap

I recently traded in my Google Pixel 8 for a Pixel 10 Pro.

My carrier regularly offers exceptional deals on Pixel devices a few months after their launch, and they didn't disappoint me with an impressive offer, including a pair of free Pixel Buds Pro 2.

The earbuds were stolen at delivery, but nevertheless, I was pleased with what I got for my money.

I then traded in my Pixel 8 for £175 ($228), so in total, I spent £552 ($721) on my new phone, and let's not forget the stolen earbuds worth £219 ($286). But I wish I hadn't done it.

While I like to keep on top of the latest Android hardware, the Pixel 8 just received a raft of updates that brought its software on par with the Pixel 10 Pro. I should have waited until the Pixel 11 to trade it in.

Related I'd still buy a Google Pixel 8 Pro in 2025, and so should you

Fantastic value and continued support

Posts 16 By Stephen Radochia Jul 31, 2025

I knew the Pixel 10 Pro was good, but it surprised me

I wasn't expecting AI-powered software to be useful

If I weren't writing about Android devices for a living, I would probably still be rocking my Pixel 6.

Nevertheless, while I like to keep up to date on hardware, trading in and buying a new phone every year is excessive.

Two years is the minimum time you should wait before upgrading your phone, and only when there's a notable increase in quality.

I knew the Pixel 10 Pro would be an upgrade, but it was an unexpected set of features that stood out for me.

Its beautiful display, restrained application of AI, and stunning cameras are the highlights of the phone, but at the end of the day, it's the software experience I care about.

If you're thinking about buying a Pixel phone based on its software features, you should definitely think twice.

Pixel Feature Drops regularly bring features exclusive to new phones to older ones. Tensor-equipped Pixel devices (such as the Pixel 6 or later) are well served by these updates.

However, what I wasn't expecting was how quickly Google would bring the Pixel 10's software to older devices.

Where's my exclusive software now?

The Pixel 8 feels like a Pixel 10 Pro

Google Pixel 8 Pro held up against a Google Pixel 10 Pro XL

In November's Pixel Feature Drop, Google brought the Pixel Journal app, a new phone maintenance menu, and Recorder upgrades to the Pixel 8 and other Pixel devices.

It also received brand-new features like scam detection for chat, a magnifier, an improved home screen search bar, and some AI-powered photo editing tools you can safely ignore.

I use the Pixel Journal and Recorder apps nearly every day on my Pixel 10 Pro. I struggle to write down my thoughts, so I use Recorder to summarize them. I can talk aimlessly for minutes, and the app will have a decent idea of what I was thinking.

After trying and failing for months, Pixel Journal finally helped me start journaling; its AI-powered insights are perfect when I'm stuck for what to write about.

Both these features are now on the Pixel 8, less than three months after the launch of the Pixel 10.

If it weren't for the Pixel 10's camera upgrade, I would be deeply frustrated

Better hardware is the best reason to upgrade to a new Pixel phone

You're missing something with the Pixel 10 screenshot

I'm not a photographer, but the Pixel 8's camera was so frustrating that I was glad to leave it behind.

While the photos are clear, the post-processing removes the vibrancy from colors. It spoiled my holiday snaps on more than one occasion, so I was pleased to see the Pixel 10 Pro's camera bring the life back to my photography.

The Pixel 10 Pro's display is another significant hardware upgrade, but it's the camera that is the standout hardware feature here. But that's only because the Pixel 8's camera was so disappointing.

If the Pixel 8's camera had captured the vibrant colors of my subjects, I would have been much more cautious about upgrading to the Pixel 10 Pro.

But now it feels like the camera is the only notable upgrade after all the good software features have made their way to the Pixel 8.

The Pixel 10 Pro still has exclusive software features. However, they're either so niche you won't use them or useless.

ProRes Zoom falls into the former category. 100x zoom is impressive, but I never need to use it in my day-to-day life.

Magic Cue could be amazing, but it has not worked once on my phone since I started using it.

Camera Coach is probably the most useless of the bunch; I hope Google lets it die rather than wasting hours bringing it to older phones.

A 3-year cycle seems wise, considering Google's rapid software updates

I'll continue to regularly replace my Pixel phone, but if I wasn't actively thinking about Android on a day-to-day basis, I would switch to a three- or four-year cycle at minimum.

I applaud Google's rapid rollout of new software features to older phones; it makes the most of their seven-year update life, but it makes buying a new Pixel increasingly irrelevant.

Unless you're considering the hardware as your primary reason for upgrading to a new Pixel, don't bother.

Source: Google Like Follow Followed Google Pixel 8 SoC Google Tensor G3 RAM 8GB Storage 128GB, 256GB Battery 4,575mAh Ports USB-C Operating System Android 14
The Google Pixel 8 is Google's best phone yet, and it's the most distinct regular model when compared to the Pro version. It comes with a wonderful form factor that fits well in the hands and has the usual software prowess that you expect from a Pixel.
$699 at Amazon $699 at Best Buy $699 at Google Store Expand Collapse
Google Pixel 10 Pro SoC Google Tensor G5 RAM 16GB Storage 128 GB / 256 GB / 512 GB with Zoned UFS / 1 TB with Zoned UFS Battery 4870mAh Operating System Android 16 Front camera 42 MP Dual PD selfie camera
Google's latest Pro Pixel packs a faster yet efficient Tensor G5 chip, an upgraded ISP, and a brighter display. Plus, an array of new AI features that make it one of the best Android phones to launch in 2025.
$999 at Amazon $999 at Best Buy Expand Collapse

Phones
Google
Google Pixel 8

Follow Followed Like Share Facebook X WhatsApp Threads Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit Flipboard Copy link Email Close Thread Sign in to your Android Police account

We want to hear from you! Share your opinions in the thread below and remember to keep it respectful.

Be the first to post Images Attachment(s) Please respect our community guidelines. No links, inappropriate language, or spam.

Your comment has not been saved

Send confirmation email

This thread is open for discussion.

Be the first to post your thoughts.